Search the site

Growing Leaders Blog

on Leading the Next Generation

huffington
foxfriendslogo-thumb

The Balance Between Empowerment and Performance

I’ve developed another theory based on research I’ve done on student athletes and their corresponding adult coaches and parents. After interpreting the results of a coaches’ poll recently, it is clear that resilience among kids today is diminishing. In fact, while young people have many advantages kids did not enjoy fifty years ago, they are showing a decline in personal drive and a rise in mental health issues. In short: ambition is down, anxiety is up.

What’s up with that?

As adults, we push our kids because we see so much potential in them. They often feel, however, that adults push them too hard, and that playing sports is more about pleasing dad or a coach instead of about the fun of the game. HBO is currently running a special program called, “The State of Play: Trophy Kids.” It’s about this gap between kids and their parents (and even their coaches).

trophy

Let me decipher what is happening millions of times around the U.S.

From ages 5-10, kids are awarded trophies just for participating in sports or other activities. However, between ages 10-18, students begin to be pushed by their parents to work harder. This causes some students to experience emotional trauma, as hard work was not embedded in their upbringing. Suddenly, ambition and resilience plummet. We’re shocked. But to students, parents who have lived vicariously through them suddenly transition from Dr. Jekyll to Mr. Hyde.

Here is the sequence that happens millions of times each week:

  • For parents, teachers, coaches, we see a lack of ambition in students.
  • We also see so much potential inside we don’t want them to miss.
  • We begin to challenge them to be and do more, to put out more effort.
  • Eventually—we create a Performance Trap, where they begin believing our approval of them is completely dependent on their achievement.

Sometimes, even nominal amounts of pressure turn into a Performance Trap for them because we failed to build resilience and identity—they want to quit, when the smallest obstacle surfaces. It’s not fun…because it’s not easy. We should’ve built a love for the struggle, but we didn’t. Their motivation quietly shifts from a love of the game to pleasing a parent or coach. It’s artificial and won’t stand the test of time. And if they decide to stay in the sport, they become mentally or emotional unhealthy.

If parents and coaches hadn’t made the mistake of rewarding everything in our young children—when the stakes are very low—we would have better prepared them mentally and emotionally for adolescence. In fact, I contend that keeping score and providing trophies to only the highest achievers will actually boost the self-esteem in our children. They would comprehend the value of achievement and aspire to it. When everyone gets a reward, its value drops and it begins to mean nothing. This does not bolster self-esteem—it boosts narcissism. It’s artificial confidence that unfortunately can’t withstand the pressure we apply when they grow older and we expect more. It’s like building a house with heavy bricks and sheet rock on a foundation of sand. Of course it won’t stand up to the weight—it’s not sturdy. So, our kids advance into adolescence with greater levels of depression and anxiety than any generation of children in modern history. We did a disservice to them.

Moving From Performance Traps to Empowerment

May I suggest the following initial steps for you as a coach or parent:

  1. Help them establish their identity outside of a sport or a course.
  2. Affirm your support and belief in them, regardless of their talent.
  3. Consistently affirm variables that are in their control, such as effort.
  4. With their help, establish standards for them to aspire to as they perform.
  5. Reward them only when they reach those standards.
  6. Continually communicate the potential you see in them.

Dr. Michael Unger, a child therapist, writes: “We seem these days to have a magical notion that children can learn…by just watching and listening to others talk about it. That just isn’t the way our brains develop. We are experiential beings. Lev Vygotsky, a famous child psychologist from Russia, demonstrated very well what he calls ‘zones of proximal development.’ We need to be pushed, not too far, but just enough to learn something new. Good development occurs when we are invited to accept challenges that are just big enough to demand we work at solving them, but that they don’t completely defeat us.”

One more thing. The surest way to develop an unhealthy student athlete (or “mathlete” for that matter) is to vicariously live your life through them. If your identity is too closely tied to their performance, it always leads to trouble. In short, we adults need to get a life, too.

52-Leadership-IdeasVB-Cropped

For daily ideas on leading kids well, subscribe to our blog here.

After you confirm your subscription, you’ll be sent a link to download 52 Leadership Ideas absolutely FREE.

4 Comments

  1. Kim Brackin on December 16, 2013 at 7:53 am

    Great article and advice. HBO special is great, painful most of the time but great. It was clear each of those parents made their children’s competition about them – even the mom who tries to persuade her sons that is was for the glory of God.
    I agree w you: establish their identity outside of sport and affirm effort! Thanks as always Tim!

  2. Nevell - Corona, CA on December 16, 2013 at 11:37 am

    I agree and disagree with the article, as a Little League Baseball/Pop Warner football coach, both 5-10, and 10-8th graders, I used the trophy system to reward kids in certain areas in which they improved. I did give an MVP, Offensive, Defensive, and Pitcher Award to the top performers, and I would always have the kids/coaches vote on the MVP. I also gave awards for the kid that didn’t have the talent but came to practice everyday and gave 100% at practice and during the games he got in. But one thing I never did, was put a big emphasis on winning, the first thing I would always say the first day of practice, was this was an extension of the class room and we are here to learn the sport and each game was a test against the other teams in out league to see how we did. To this day, I still have relationships with almost every kid I ever coached, rather they are playing a sport, the band, or studying. The hardest thing I dealt with was having a son on each team and sharing his time with his teammates, but he was cool with it, and we had a blast each and every year.

    • Tim Elmore on December 18, 2013 at 9:38 am

      Thank you for sharing, Nevell. I believe we are on the same page. I agree that we should only affirm the kids’ actions that are within their control. You seem to be doing that with these trophies. It seems you are a great coach and father who loves his kids and the game. Thank you for leading today’s students.

Leave a Comment





The Balance Between Empowerment and Performance